Benelli sbe2 vs beretta a400 there are no reliability issues to be a concern. 5 Feb 17, 2022 · On the gas side, we have the Browning Maxus 2, The Winchester SX4, and the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus. Soft shooting and well balanced. Aug 22, 2024 · When it comes to waterfowl shotguns, two guns that seem to come up most often are the Benelli SBE3, and the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus. The Beretta definitely kicks less, though for waterfowl it doesn't make that much difference for me - I just don't shoot that much. Let's get into this! I started out with a baseline test: I cleaned all the guns the same way and used the same lubricant. Both are soft shooting and easy to handle. A couple buddies had issues with various Benelli’s. I sold it and am now thinking about the Beretta A400 xtreme plus. It's really going to come down to the ergonomics and how they pull up for you. Sep 27, 2018 · Benelli Super black Eagle 3 vs Beretta a400 unico extreme Jump to Latest 29K views 28 replies 14 participants last post by PJD Sep 5, 2019 P Aug 6, 2013 · Hello I'm in the market for a shotgun. I personally like the ergonomics of the beretta a little better. Jul 28, 2022 · Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus or Benelli SBE3. That is duck hunting scenario, benelli click is still a thing. Gas guns are smoother to me but need more maintenance compared to inertia guns. net is sponsored by Beretta. I am looking for a new shotgun and want a semi automatic in camo and 3. I'm mainly interested in it for turkey and waterfowl hunting. Anyone got any info, likes, dislikes, anything at all really about these. Parts 2 and 3 Aug 27, 2018 · As far as Benelli/Beretta inertia/gas goes, I personally prefer the feel of Benelli's inertia guns much more over gas guns. Aug 8, 2024 · Benelli xtrema???? Click to expand Wires crossed. My SBE2 fits me better than any gun I've ever shot. These differences, although sometimes subtle, are crucial for proper and safe function. Jul 27, 2010 · Beretta A400 Xplor (28" w/ KO) or Benelli SBEII ? Jump to Latest 1. Good call. All of the guns shoulder nicely, with the Benelli's maybe having a slight advantage. After duck season sold an 1100 20 and got the A400 Upland 20. The Browning, Beretta or Benelli will all be great workhorses anyone saying otherwise is just a fanboy. Beretta. Please let me know your thoughts and opinions on both or either one. Any reviews on Beretta A400 xplor action Or Benelli Montefeltro Silver will help. . Jun 22, 2015 · The A400 is an excellent gas operated shotgun. Also open to other options. I owned two of the watefowl model the "extreme plus" and my duck hunting partners shoot the xplor. 3. I've been reading a lot about it and so far (I think) I've narrowed it down to the Benelli SBE II or the Beretta A400. Oct 13, 2022 · The Beretta gas guns will handle light target loads much better than the SBE. Anybody have first hand experience with th Oct 30, 2018 · I went from a Benelli SBE to the new A400 in camo. Sep 16, 2024 · A300 vs A400 vs Franchi Affinity vs SBE3 Jump to Latest 6K views 42 replies 24 participants last post by Joe Leb Oct 3, 2025 C Dec 28, 2023 · Hello all, Looking at purchasing a left handed 3. For example, you can get replace springs from Wolff for the Benelli SBE. The A400 shot true point of aim/impact, and it also had a pretty decent-looking pattern distribution. An a400 breaks down literally in 15 seconds. It has less recoil than the Benelli's and is considered highly by clay target shooters (unlike the SBE or M2). 5 inch chamber 12 gauge. I would suggest just grabbing all your choices and really look them over. Teddy Roosevelt Feb 7, 2024 · The Beretta A400’s softer recoil and ergonomic design may be more forgiving for new shooters. Is this still an issue with the newer M2s and SBE? It certainly leads to a loss of confidence in the gun. Choosing between the two ultimately comes down to personal preferences, shooting needs, and budget. I’m currently leaning towards the Beretta A400 extreme plus. I personally think the A400 action is smoother, due to the gas system vs the inertia in the SBE 3. Given the opportunity I would take my 2 back from my father and give him the 3 but he’s wise to the fact that it doesn’t shoot In conclusion, both the Beretta A400 and Benelli Super Black Eagle III are exceptional semi-auto shotguns that offer reliability, performance, and durability. I am a beretta O/U fan but my duck/goose gun is currently a benelli nova. Jul 11, 2024 · Having shot the a400 and the sbe3, I would go with the a400. Benelli guys love their Benelli's and Beretta guys love their Beretta's. Oct 4, 2024 · Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 vs. Nov 14, 2024 · Not wanting to bash, but rather more curious why Benelli SBE’s are looked upon as the holy grail of duck hunting autos according to a dedicated duck hunting friend of mine. Beretta A400 Xtrema vs Benelli SBE Last edited: Aug 11, 2024 Aug 10, 2024 #17 Feb 17, 2022 · On the gas side, we have the Browning Maxus 2, The Winchester SX4, and the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus. Oct 3, 2025 · I think the Affinity 3 is what the SBE3 should have been - a decent update to the SBE2, with predictable shooting characteristics (looking at you, Benelli), good overall quality, and a price that seems commensurate with the low level of complexity in its inertia action. Apr 28, 2023 · In this post, we will be comparing two popular shotguns in the waterfowl hunting world: Benelli and Beretta. Anybody have first hand experience with th May 8, 2018 · I own models of Beretta and Benelli, and my SBE2 has become my go-to gun for almost all occasions. Jul 2, 2016 · I’ve never shot the Benelli SBE, but I hunt ducks and geese on the Eastern Shore of MD with the Benelli M2. THANKS Also make sure you understand the various models of the A400 - Xplorer, Xcel and Xtrema and the various options for each model. The extema the length of pull was long and non adjustable. No offense intended, very serious about that, but TravisMears. I had a Benelli SBE II in black and didn't like the recoil on the 3. Good choices bad choices? Any help would be greatly appreciated Oct 3, 2025 · I think the Affinity 3 is what the SBE3 should have been - a decent update to the SBE2, with predictable shooting characteristics (looking at you, Benelli), good overall quality, and a price that seems commensurate with the low level of complexity in its inertia action. Re: Beretta A400 extreme vs benelli SBE2? [Re: Raider07] #4414485 07/23/1308:37 PM Joined: Jan 2010 Posts: 23,830 B beaversnipe THF Celebrity beaversnipe THF Celebrity B Joined: Jan 2010 Posts: 23,830 Save your money and buy 870 pump Best gun for conservation hunt, mud, rain, etc. Took the 20 on a Teal hunt last and with Boss 3” shells the just over 6lb did feel like the recoil of a 12. Also ive read that if you dont quite shoulder the Benelli properly is wont cycle the shells because of the gun being an inertia driven shotgun. Never owning a benelli before I Feb 22, 2020 · I have a SBE2 and has experienced the benelli click. 5 Dec 6, 2020 · I have two Benelli's (SBE2 and M1) and two Beretta's (12 and 20 ga Urika AL391's). They mitigate recoil fairly well. All that said, I sold my a400s and now shoot Benelli's. Keep that in mind when you contemplate whether you pull the trigger more at the range or in the field. What makes the Beretta A400 and Benelli Ethos stand out in terms of design and aesthetics? Dec 13, 2011 · Im lookin to get a new shotgun and was hoping for some info. With carefully considered insights from our pro-staff and veteran hunters, Benelli design engineers have spent nearly 10 years in development with a focus on three areas of critical importance to the serious waterfowler: Improved ergonomics, intuitive, flawless functionality and an updated design, style and feel for the No offense intended, very serious about that, but TravisMears. Today we're going to do a shotgun showdown between these two shotguns to finally determine which of these is the better pick for waterfowl hunting. Right now I am considering the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus, Benelli SBE III, and the Browning A5. I like gas guns vs inertia guns. Nov 28, 2014 · It has a more sleek feel vs what I think of as bulky feel with the a400. Compare the Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 and Beretta A400: This analysis examines pricing, specifications, pros, cons, and available deals to inform your pur Nov 10, 2022 · BERETTA A400 EXTREME PLUS - This gun was tied with the 940 PRO for the highest pellet percentage in the 30" circle at 81%. I don’t love that. I know it's not the A400 vs SBE3 matchup you're asking about, but my Beretta 391 rarely comes out of the safe anymore now that I've got the Benelli. I see no one has mentioned how FAST Beretta blink system is. For example, the A400 Xcel comes in three sub-models - sporting, parallel target and multi-target. Jan 1, 2024 · Benelli vs Beretta (SBE3 vs a400) Review! Watch on Diversity is the greatest weakness, excellence is the greatest strength. Never jams even with 1 oz loads so I guess I'm lucky about that, but I would expect any Beretta to be the same. Both smoothbore camps are well entrenched, firm believers that the brand they shoot is better than the other. When it comes to hunting loads all cycle well. To the OP: of the two guns you are considering, I'd go with the A400. It has been sent back to Benelli and it has not changed anything. Benelli in blued/wood and the Beretta in grey/black. 5” will take 3” shells. Today Bought my SBE3 several years ago now after having much success with my SBE2. Apr 9, 2021 · I have narrowed down my choices for a semi auto 28 gauge to the Beretta A400 Xplor and the Benelli Ethos Cordoba with the BeST finish. , and Academy and have shouldered a Beretta A400 Extreme Unica, a Benelli SBE II, a Beretta Extrema II and a Benelli Super Vinci. Think of the Benelli like the girl you took home from the bar, she might be fun for a night or two but you don't want to marry her. When the SBE 1 and Beretta Extrema came out years ago I purchased both because I couldn't choose. I didn't need to, but I did. These are all 12 gauges. As far as the beretta, sure a gas gun may have slight more maintenance necessary…. May 26, 2021 · Beretta has 400 series shotguns that have soft combs but I can't find that they are replaceable with various comb heights like the SBE. Ive seen some posts about the Benelli failing to cycle lighter loads i. As for the Beretta, i havent found a whole lot of issues on Benelli SBE3 VS. Besides inertia vs gas also SBE has raised rib vs A400 flat rib. Eve Jan 1, 2024 · Benelli vs Beretta (SBE3 vs a400) Review! Watch on Diversity is the greatest weakness, excellence is the greatest strength. Apr 7, 2013 · Bought an A400 Extreme June/21. JPC No offense intended, very serious about that, but TravisMears. Apr 22, 2016 · I've narrowed it down to these two. 5" capable. Huge Difference when hunting and caused some frustration as I missed shots I had not missed in decades. Either is fine for walking. I personally find the SBE 3 more reliable, tied for the A400. Feel And fit is going to be your big difference with these two guns. However, when it comes to duck hunting, which one of these shotguns is better? Let's dive deep into each platform to uncov Mar 23, 2020 · I went SBE 3 while my dad has two of the A400 Xtreme Plus's and I really like both, you can't go wrong with either and not one of the guns has had an issue. Jan 6, 2013 · I have been to the sporting goods department at Gander Mt. The Benelli may kick more. SBE 3 – the full redesign of our venerable Super Black Eagle platform. 5". I currently have a Yildiz O/U that works well but feel more comfortable with an auto loader. In this video we go over all the features of the Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 (SBE3) and The Beretta a400 Extreme Plus (a400). The Benelli's have each had far more problems in the field than my Beretta has. Sep 29, 2020 · I am looking for a new shotgun and want a semi automatic in camo and 3. Stuck between getting the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus or the Benelli Super Black Eagle III? Maybe this 3 part series can help make your decision. Jan 2, 2024 · Which is better — Beretta 1301 vs Benelli M4? It depends on use: the Benelli M4 (ARGO gas) is built as a rugged, military/tactical workhorse with extreme reliability under hard use; the Beretta 1301 is lighter, faster-handling, and excellent for home defense or competition. Sep 2, 2021 · The Video includes the full head-to-head Shotgun Showdown of the Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 vs the Browning Maxus 2 but if you prefer to read about it, below is a quick summary. I looked at the SBE but went the Beretta route and haven’t looked back. I can only assume its because the Beretta stocks were fatter vs slim / narrow Benelli and i'm guessing i just didnt get it mounted consistently. 9K views 6 replies 3 participants last post by Gregg8 Jul 30, 2010 ajamils Discussion starter Aug 29, 2025 · I am looking for a new shotgun and want a semi automatic in camo and 3. As for reliability that’s a wash, the benelli inertia system is fantastic, however A400, is going to cycle light target loads better than the benelli. Therefore I am tied; I understand the difference in the cycling between the two. I finally switched to a Beretta A400 plus and have been super happy. Basically, it's a good deal. Oct 28, 2018 · It's a sickness more then anything lol! I'm that way with 3/4 ton diesel trucks as well as beretta shotguns. For reference I have 3 Beretta A400 excels for sporting and they are almost ubiquitous for a semi auto in that game Jan 26, 2020 · Benelli SBE III or Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus khunter20 Apr 10, 2020 Prev 1 2 3 Next No offense intended, very serious about that, but TravisMears. This is why I chose the m2 when looking at beretta vs benelli a few years ago. 5" steel. They swing better for me Aug 4, 2012 · hey guys my school has a skeet shooting team and i was wondering if i should get a benelli sport II 12ga or a beretta a400 xcel 12ga as a new skeet gun. Oct 1, 2020 · I am looking for a new shotgun and want a semi automatic in camo and 3. e 2 3/4" versus 3. Kind of a senseless argument if you ask me. If you plan to use the same shotgun for clay target shooting though, the Beretta might be a better choice. Apr 5, 2015 · Love my A400 very reliable have thousands of rounds through it in a duck blind. Anybody have first hand experience with th Jul 2, 2016 · I was spoiled with picking a Beretta AL390 from my uncle for $300, my vote is the A400. 9K views 6 replies 3 participants last post by Gregg8 Jul 30, 2010 ajamils Discussion starter Dec 6, 2020 · I have two Benelli's (SBE2 and M1) and two Beretta's (12 and 20 ga Urika AL391's). I've shot my SBE2 side by side to my brother's A400, and I just like my SBE2 better. i wish you could just buy a new up graded bolt but that's just me the SBE3 is a softer shooting gun . Feb 27, 2014 · I shoot a Beretta and hunt with three guys who shoot Benelli's. Every year I do at least one conservation hunt that No offense intended, very serious about that, but TravisMears. I really like the feel and look of the SBE 3, but am really nervous about buying a shotgun that The beretta forend is a little larger feeling and because the gas system is on the middle of the barrel it balances farther forward. Feb 28, 2023 · Beretta's Kick-Off is very effective, but I don't believe the Outlander is available with that feature. The main concerns would be gas vs inertia. A Beretta SV10 Perinnia in 20 gauge for doves, quail, and other small game. Oct 2, 2021 · My research shows SBE 3 vs A400 is like a Chevy vs Ford debate…everyone has a preference. I can't speak for the A400, but the Benelli will cycle absolutely anything. My personal preference would be gas over inertia, although I recognize the latter is likely the more reliable system. And since it’s a high quality well made piece of hardware…. Feb 13, 2017 · I also shoot a Benelli SBE II for ducks and love it. We tell you about all the featu Feb 7, 2015 · I have the SBE2 and I had a Beretta A300, not the 400. Nov 6, 2023 · Hello everyone, I've recently become very interested in the world of semi-auto field and skeet shotguns and have narrowed my search down between the Beretta A300 field and Benelli M2 field. Nov 10, 2022 · BERETTA A400 EXTREME PLUS - This gun was tied with the 940 PRO for the highest pellet percentage in the 30" circle at 81%. If you pick up both, I would imagine you will like the feel of one better than the other. I already have a Remington 870 Supermangum in 12 gauge dedicated for turkeys. They do require more cleaning than an inertia gun like the Monte, but they shoot well and that gas system is mucho reliable and fast. Jun 3, 2020 · I have a Beretta AL390 (preceded the model you mentioned by a few decades I believe) and really love that gun. The Beretta gas guns will cycle lighter loads and have less recoil. Thanks A buddy is a Benelli fan and shoots an SBE II and remarked how different they are (they are - we traded guns that day). I believe it has to do with bumping the slide/charging handle that takes it out of battery. I'm looking more toward reliability during tough conditions while shooting a lot. Fit wise I liked the Benelli better. Feb 10, 2022 · Beretta's latest attempt at an affordable 3-inch semi-auto is the A300 Ultima, which is a feature-packed and functional synthetic shotgun. I was hoping to get some opinions and thoughts on these shotguns and Benelli SBE3 VS. I have read for hours about each gun,and still can’t come to a decision. Forcing a choke designed for one brand into a shotgun from the other can lead to: Damage to the Choke Tube: The threads can be stripped or deformed No offense intended, very serious about that, but TravisMears. Super Black… | Grand View Outdoors Here's a nice comparison. The Benelli Ethos, while slightly more challenging due to its recoil profile, is still a great choice due to its simplicity and ease of use. anyone who has one of these shotguns please tell me how it performs as in shooting clays. Sep 29, 2012 · Upgrading my shotgun and I am stuck between the Beretta A400, Benelli Cordoba or the Benelli Super Black Eagle II. Oct 30, 2024 · Why Beretta and Benelli Chokes Differ The primary reason for the incompatibility lies in the different threading and dimensions used by Beretta and Benelli. I don't think he can even consider recommending a Benelli based off of sponsorships. Dec 28, 2023 · The Benelli is a much racier gun that is lighter and more lively in the hands, but I question its reliability. Feb 25, 2025 · When it comes to shotguns, there’s probably no more hotly contested debate than Benelli vs. Re: Beretta A400 extreme vs benelli SBE2? [Re: Raider07] #4414485 07/23/1308:37 PM Joined: Jan 2010 Posts: 23,839 B beaversnipe THF Celebrity beaversnipe THF Celebrity B Joined: Jan 2010 Posts: 23,839 Save your money and buy 870 pump Best gun for conservation hunt, mud, rain, etc. I use my shotgun for dove hunting, shooting clays and very rarely duck/geese hunting all done in South Texas. Main choices are the Beretta A400 Xtreme or either the Benelli SBE2 or the M2. It fits me, cycles flawlessly, and just feels quality. Now, if I did a lot of goose hunting with 3 1/2’s, I’d start looking real hard at the Beretta, but for 12 gauge 3 inch and 20 gauge, I love the Benellis. I love the gun, it shoulders easily and is super light with very little kick. Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus | Shotgun Showdown - When it comes to waterfowl shotguns, two names come up more than others - The Benelli SBE3, and the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus. I'm going to buy one of these shotguns this year. Neither one is better, but they shoot and shoulder differently. Thoughts and experience? May 24, 2024 · Looking for a good 20ga shotgun. but it’s not hard. In my experience it has been much more reliable than the sbe3. Both my inertia guns have hiccupped from time to time, on a bad crimp, or shooting slugs (M1 was for 3gun). I bought a Benelli SBE in 20 gauge for my daughter and it kicks about the same as my Beretta. Dedicated waterfowl gun, need it to perform in cold,nasty conditions. Thanks. I was originally looking at a Winchester SX4 but couldn’t find any for a price close to MSRP and figured if I am going to be spending over 1100 anyway I might as well get premium gun. The Maxus 2, mine anyways, is picky on ammunition. overall, I like the shotgun, but have missed shots at birds due to the “Benelli click”. I recently picked up a left hand Benelli m2 20 gauge and love it. Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus: Compare top waterfowl shotguns for performance, durability, and recoil to find your best fit. My primary use will be skeet/trap shooting and still have the option to take it hunting for waterfowl No offense intended, very serious about that, but TravisMears. 5 inch chamber, kick off 2 and will cycle anything you feed into it. Beretta A400 extreme vs benelli SBE2? - 07/23/1308:31 PM I'm going to buy one of these shotguns this year. Let us speak courteously, deal fairly, and keep ourselves armed and ready. Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus | Shotgun Showdown LAWYER: Say THESE WORDS When Cops Ask About Your Gun Expensive but worth it? Benelli Ethos Cordoba BEST 12ga Shotgun Review Jun 8, 2017 · I work part time at a local gun store and we sell those A400 Xplor Unico's Synthetic's all day, 30 inch barrel, 3. Feb 29, 2024 · How does a benelli with same stock drops as the beretta not snap up and shoot the same in the field. I haven’t shot the SBE3 and they’re supposedly great guns but I’m A400 all the way. However, it 100% hits high and left. Another nice thing about Benelli shotguns is that due to their popularity, you can always find replace parts like springs for them easily. On the Inertia side, we have the Benelli SBE 3, the Stoeger M3500, and the Franchi Affinity 3. Dec 8, 2018 · The Benelli folks will criticize the weight/size of the Beretta and the Beretta folks will criticize the recoil of the Beretta. That said, my Beretta is not an A400 (it's an Xtrema2) and the problematic Benelli's are all SBE"s. Look at the things like the bolt, safety Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 VS Browning Maxus 2 | Shotgun Showdown: If you've got a pretty penny and are looking to get a premier waterfowl shotgun, these options from Benelli and Browning are No offense intended, very serious about that, but TravisMears. Both brands offer high-quality firearms that are used by hunters and shooters worldwide. The Benelli had ported barrels, which I didn't care for, but it was accurate and reliable. The weight between the Maxus 2 and SBE 3 is negligible, so whoever said SBE 3 is way lighter doesn’t own both. Anyone with likes or dislikes will be helpful. Oct 8, 2019 · Gun review: Benelli Super Vinci vs. vtsy bnhtqy gwl voxre yzzx agat sbtg oixskdd loi ddqdp vsd kms zuyh tjhbm qceh